One veteran programmer and one new programmer had the New York upfront spotlight to themselves Tuesday night. In one corner: Scripps Networks' family of lifestyle channels. In the other: Revolt, Sean Combs' six-month-old music-driven service.
Scripps Networks Interactive
Venue : Alice Tully Hall on the corner of Broadway and W. 65th St. Logos and titles of Scripps' channels flanked the glass walls of this Lincoln Center structure (upgraded several years ago), while food stations offering a wide range of tasty treats from pepper-jack turkey sliders to Indian chicken were spaced throughout the lobby. In one of several pre-ceremony moves, attendees had more than an hour to taste some delicacies and snap selfies with various channel personalities, including Guy Fieri from Food Network, HGTV's Property Brothers, Samantha Brown and her Travel Channel colleagues and Vanilla Ice (featured on DIY Network). More food kudos to the caterer handling the Scripps press gathering Tuesday morning for a menu featuring kiwi/honeydew and pomegranate/strawberry juice, Nutella-banana turnovers and matza brey (for press marking the final day of Passover). Grade : 5 Jacks, plus a special 9 Jacks for the food.
Presentation : A throwback to the days when senior advertising sales executives routinely were lead-off speakers, making the key points on the channel's behalf. The current pecking order is chief executive, followed by key programming executives, with the ad sales advocate speaking midway or at the end. But Scripps had ad sales and marketing president Steve Gillotti bat first. Assisted by a clear and classy set of graphics at the back of the stage, Gillotti offered the view that real-time lifestyle programming is a slam-dunk audience attraction. In the process, he whipped up some of the best punch lines at any upfront so far in 2014. On more channels experimenting with similar content: "We're not testing the waters. We own the whole damn lake, and the lake's getting bigger." Other choice cuts: "Our audiences do what they view” ... “People look to us to inspire transformation in their lives” ... and the best of them all, “Our viewers see the advertising as a resource, not an interruption." From there, various channel presidents (Brooke Johnson for Food/Cooking Channel), Kathleen Finch (HGTV/DIY) and Travel Channel newcomer Shannon O'Neill mixed current/future highlights with an on-stage personality interview. Grade: 4.5 Jacks
News : Easy pickings with six channels on display. HGTV's upcoming calendar includes a new Ellen DeGeneres-hosted design competition next year and Jennie Garth with a home renovation series this September. The Big Tip, Food's new Rachael Ray program (August), turns the camera on waiters and waitresses that go beyond the call of customers. American Diner Revival, The Great Holiday Bake-Off and Rapid Fire Restaurant are among the fall attractions. Upcoming Cooking Channel series include Carnival Eats, Proper Pub Food and Sarah Graham's Food Safari. A pair of notable Travel Channel projects: One Day On Earth, a special (that may become a series) covering 24 hours as witnessed by production crews from more than 190 countries, and Breaking Borders, featuring award-winning reporter Marianne van Zeller (Vanguard) and chef Michael Voltaggio uncovering culture inside hot spots worldwide. Think the Middle East and North/South Korea. DIY's new series lineup takes a celebrity turn with separate efforts from William Shatner (The Shatner Project) and Daryl Hall of Hall & Oates (Daryl's Restoration Over-Hall). Grade: 5 Jacks
Host : Everyone handled their portion effortlessly, although several of the celebrity interviews went too long (especially Finch's turn with the Property Brothers). Ditto Jon Steinlauf, the executive originator of Scripps' unique sponsorship showcase. Best of this profiled bunch: Wayfair.com's "Shop the Show" collaboration with HGTV. Grade: 4.5 Jacks
Overall Grade: 4.5 Jacks Outstanding mix of script, videos (the opener for Travel Channel was a textbook example of creative editing) and graphic displays. Special note: Half-jack subtraction for how Great American Country came off. Nice video and a pair of personalities getting acknowledged, but no commentary on new programming, compounded by the absence of that information in press kits distributed Tuesday morning.
Venue : Marquee, the nightclub/concert venue on 10th Ave. between W. 26-27 Sts. Packed crowd on hand to see the channel up close for themselves, six months after its launch. Simple display, with small monitors on either side of the stage. Bars throughout the space served drinks before and after the presentation, and the post-game show featured performers Childish Gambino (singer/rapper who often reminds you of John Legend) and Dillon Francis, plus DJs spinning tunes. Grade: 4 Jacks
Presentation : The bottom line from every executive or talent up on stage was uniform. This is a channel about music and giving everyone from superstars to musicians in any genre a chance to break in. "We're the influence that influences the influencers," chief executive officer Keith Clinkscales noted without breaking into a tongue-twisting sweat. (That’s another nominee for top 2014 upfront quote.) When the team of executives that Revolt chairman Sean Combs organized to run his channel wasn't making points, Combs himself was, weaving in and out of the proceedings at will. At every turn, Combs assured us that Revolt will set innovative ad collaborations and that nothing is off the table. Pointing to a monitor presenting the Fiat new car model spot with -- you guessed it -- "Happy" playing in the background, Combs said, “That Fiat commercial gave them their No. 1 month in sales history. Yes, we can do anything. The buck stops here. Anything can be done if it's done the right way." The pace often dragged, and with so many people taking a turn, at times people sensed the kitchen sink would chime in if in the house. Nice surprise: An inspiring video about the recent Revolt Nation tour landing in South By Southwest and other music destinations. Grade: 3.5 Jacks
News: Advertising was the dominant headline for a change -- AT&T, Hewlett-Packard, Procter & Gamble, Pepsi and Anheuser-Busch have come aboard as recurring advertisers, plus another global advertiser, name withheld for the moment, has signed a eight-figure contract. This wasn't the place to make new programming announcements. Grade: 3 Jacks
Host : Engaging turns from Combs, Clinkscales, president Andy Schuon, programming executive vice president Val Boreland and Revolt Live co-hosts JD Damage and Sibley. Grade: 4.5 Jacks
Overall Grade: 4 Jacks Solid, if way too extensive a first shot with this kind of showcase. Tips for round two: more emphasis on the format and current and future programming -- and keep the presentation to an hour or less!
5 Jacks - Excellent
4 Jacks - Very Good
3 Jacks - Good
2 Jacks - Fair
1 Jack - Poor
0 Jacks -Worse than bad
Next up: BET and Cinemoi North America
Until the next time, stay well and stay tuned!The opinions and points of view expressed in this commentary are exclusively the views of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of MediaBizBloggers.com management or associated bloggers. MediaBizBloggers is an open thought leadership platform and readers may share their comments and opinions in response to all commentaries.