Super Bowl and Cinema Go Head to Head

The conversation was anchored by a 2016 ad effectiveness study Screenvision Media conducted with Lieberman, Inc. that evaluated the results of an automotive advertiser’s decision to run ads in cinema versus automotive ads that ran during Super Bowl 50.

The methodology was straightforward. Immediately following the Super Bowl, an online panel that watched it received a survey asking about their recall and reactions to eight automotive brand ads that aired during the Big Game.  Respondents were given up to 48 hours to complete the survey.  Most were completed within 24.

The in-theater portion was conducted from 2/9/16-2/11/16 and captured recall and reactions to the automotive cinema ad.

While consumers enjoyed the game and advertisements, the study shined a bright light on how valuable scalable premium video is these days.  The research indicated that TV advertising during the Super Bowl and in-cinema advertising are both mediums through which consumers enjoy and pay attention to brand messages, as these are the biggest canvases for advertisers to share their stories.

Ad Enjoyment (Cinema ads are enjoyed as much as Super Bowl ads)

Super Bowl Automotive 71%
Cinema Auto Brand 72%

Attentiveness to Commercials (Cinema delivers an audience who is as attentive to the ads as they are to ads in the Super Bowl)

Super Bowl Automotive 68%
Cinema Auto Brand 66%

The research also suggested that in breaking through within the current attention economy, where engagement and impact are the new currency, the immersive, distraction-free environment of the theater drove higher ad effectiveness on recall, persuasion and influence. This type of premier impact doesn’t resonate just one night of the year as during the Super Bowl, but every weekend in front of 1.3 billion annual moviegoers.

Ad Recall (Cinema delivers 3X higher ad recall than automotive Super Bowl auto ads)

Super Bowl Automotive 28%
Cinema Auto Brand 84%

Ad Persuasion (Cinema delivers +25% higher ad persuasion than Super Bowl auto ads)

Super Bowl Automotive 48%
Cinema Auto Brand 60%

Ad Influence on Consideration (Cinema delivers +49% higher consideration than Super Bowl auto ads)

Super Bowl Automotive 43%
Cinema Auto Brand 64%

“There is no doubt how much scale the Super Bowl can provide,” Sarah Barasch told me. “It’s a highly anticipated live moment with millions of viewers, but we were curious how Super Bowl ads performed when paired up against advertising in theaters on the 40-foot screen.

“We’ve seen brands run ads in both the Super Bowl and additively in-cinema, and then we’ve also seen brands choose to forego ads in the Super Bowl and only run in-cinemas,” she continued. “We found that brands were seeing very similar results in terms of scale, attentiveness and enjoyment.  However, for some metrics -- like ad recall, overall opinion and purchase intent -- the cinema ads actually outperformed ads in the Super Bowl.”

These results were reinforced by Nielsen through a June 2016 study citing TV ad attentiveness at 29% -- significantly lower than Super Bowl ad attentiveness, which we found to be 68% and significantly lower than cinema ad attentiveness.  Ad attentiveness in-theater for this one brand was 66%, which is on par with Screenvision Media’s average (although some ads far exceed this number).

“Engaging scale with experienced impact is the highest value premium video in the marketplace,” Katy Loria explained. “In today’s media landscape, this is so important given the scarcity of big impact.  The Super Bowl is once a year and there is so much pressure for it to perform at a high level, whereas we have a blockbuster every weekend and that impact is felt consistently throughout the year.”

The demand for cinema is rising fast. It’s increasingly seen as premium video and a valuable audience replacement for eroding TV impressions. While some of these impressions can be made up for through cross-platform buys, the impact, urgency and immediacy of cinema impressions, consumed in a communal fashion, creates impact like no other with the most memorable impressions in-cinema.

In the Super vs. Cinema Bowl, round one goes to cinema. Tune in next year for a rematch.

Click the social buttons above or below to share this content with your friends and colleagues.

The opinions and points of view expressed in this article are exclusively the views of the author and/or subject(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of MediaVillage.com/MyersBizNet, Inc. management or associated bloggers.

 

Mary Ellen Holden

Mary Ellen Holden is the Founder and CEO of MEH Solutions, LLC, first established in 2001.  In this capacity she provides 360° multi-platform sales, strategy, marketing, research and media intelligence to media organizations, ad agencies and resea... read more