Google’s Fine from French Regulator Reignites Discussion Around AI Use and Fair Compensation for Journalists, even as Google Continues Pushback on the JCPA

The recent fine is the latest in the French governmentamp8217s efforts to enforce a law adopted in 2019 that provides publishers and press agencies with the right to negotiate with large online platforms that use their content The law requires online service providers to obtain authorization from publishers of online news before reproducing content in a digital form and enables publishers to be compensated for reproduction of their work by online service providersAccording to the Autoritamp233 this latest fine is the fourth decision issued against Google in the last four years The Autoritamp233 previously issued injunctions against Google for failing to adhere to the French law and then imposed fines of more than amp8364 500 Million when Google failed to comply with the terms of the injunctionsAfter the injunction violations a thirdparty monitor Accuracy was appointed to ensure Google complied with its renewed commitments to the Autoritamp233 These commitments required Google to among other things negotiate in good faith with press agencies and publishers and allow such agencies to be compensated if Google reused their workThe Autoritamp233 issued this latest fine after it discovered that Google had breached its commitment to cooperate with Accuracy and more specifically failed to comply with specific commitments Google made to the Autoritamp233 including failing to negotiate in good faith based on transparent objective and nondiscriminatory criteriaThe Autoritamp233 found that Google was not acting in good faith when it used its AI chatbot amp8220Bardamp8221 since rebranded as amp8220Geminiamp8221 to scrape content off news media sites and its publishers to train its AI model without notifying either the publishers or the Autoritamp233 This lack of notification left news media sites and publishers with no recourse to negotiate remuneration Further the lack of a simple optout option meant publishers could not even decide if Google could display their content let alone negotiate how their content could be displayed by Googleamp8217s services Although the question of whether the use of news content as part of an AI services is protected has not yet been settled the Autoritamp233 said Googleamp8217s failure to inform the publishers that it was using their content for AI violated Googleamp8217s commitments to act in a transparent nondiscriminatory mannerGoogle did not contest the findings in this most recent instance of noncompliance It agreed to pay the amp8364250 Million fine but stated that the amount was disproportionate to the violations identified Google also said it has put corrective measures in place to address the issues identified by the Autoritamp233Efforts to enact similar legislation to the European law are ongoing in the United States The Journalism Competition and Preservation Act JCPA was first introduced in the last Congress and was reintroduced in 2023 The JCPA would permit eligible news organizations to negotiate collectively with online platforms Facebook Google and others allowing news publishers to be fairly compensated for their content The bill has bipartisan support Similar legislation has also been introduced in some states including California and IllinoisDonamp8217t expect Google to sit quietly if the JCPA passes The tech giant posted on its blog last Friday that itamp8217s amp8220testingamp8221 the effects of removing links to California news websites in reaction to proposed state legislation requiring Big Tech companies to pay news outlets for their content Internationally Google has been wrestling for months with both Canadian and Australian governments which enacted similar laws to Californiaamp8217s proposed bill that require online platforms to pay for publishersamp8217 contentRegulators around the world are increasingly recognizing the importance of journalism and its critical role for maintaining informed and active citizens In the US the lack of compensation from online platforms is contributing to the demise of local news outlets in many communities amp160creating an increasing number of local news deserts Efforts to enforce existing laws that allow news publishers to be fairly compensated for their content and to pass laws in other countries including the United States are important to countering these trendsThis article was written by Shannon P Sylvester and Sally A Buckman Sylvester is an Associate and Buckman is a Member in the Media Practice Group at Lerman Senter PLLC Lerman Senter is a specialized Washington DC law firm that advises clients in the media technology and telecommunications industriesamp160

Click to Make Your 2025 Contribution to Support the MediaVillage Education Foundation

Google’s Fine from French Regulator Reignites Discussion Around AI Use and Fair Compensation for Journalists, even as Google Continues Pushback on the JCPA

Publish date

Channel

The Ad Council, Huntsman Mental Health Foundation and Amazon Announce “The Mind Set” to Support Mental Health - Ad Council InSites

More Videos:

Click to Make Your 2025 Contribution to Support the MediaVillage Education Foundation

Google’s Fine from French Regulator Reignites Discussion Around AI Use and Fair Compensation for Journalists, even as Google Continues Pushback on the JCPA

Enjoying This Commentary? There's More to Love

TAGS:

The Ad Council, Huntsman Mental Health Foundation and Amazon Announce “The Mind Set” to Support Mental Health - Ad Council InSites

The payment was successful

Cookies