Culture Clash in the Denim Aisle: What the Sydney Sweeney/American Eagle Controversy Teaches Us About Marketing in a Polarized World

It is layered regional generational and deeply personal And yet too often we design campaigns as if weamp8217re speaking to an audience with a single universally agreedupon set of values and aestheticsIn this case American Eagle a brand long associated with youthful optimism and inclusivity tapped actress Sydney Sweeney amp8211 Gen Z icon Euphoria star and an amp8220it girlamp8221 of the moment for a campaign celebrating denim Sweeneyamp8217s image however carries baggage for some audiences Her perceived political affiliations family associations and curated lifestyle became lightning rods sparking backlash and calls for boycott across social mediaTo others the outrage felt overwrought After all wasn39t this simply an attractive young woman wearing jeans on a vintage truckExactly And thatamp8217s the problemThe cultural disconnect wasnamp8217t about the campaign itself which was benign enough it was about the assumptions behind it Assumptions that everyone would see Sydney Sweeney the same way Assumptions that amp8220Americanaamp8221 reads the same across geographies and identities Assumptions that a brand can be amp8220neutralamp8221 in a hyperaware hyperfragmented cultural landscapeAnd in those assumptions the campaign stepped on a cultural landmineThe Isolation Problem in Modern MarketingIf thereamp8217s a larger lesson here itamp8217s this when marketers become too insulated by their bubble their bias or their worldview they risk losing their cultural peripheral visionWe now operate in an age where the people who create marketing campaigns often live very different lives from the people who receive them Coastal cities donamp8217t necessarily reflect middle America Urban Gen Z culture doesnamp8217t map neatly onto suburban Gen Alpha And personal beliefs affiliations or even fashion choices can be loaded with symbolic meaning we may not fully graspMarketing is at its core a discipline of empathy But empathy requires effort Itamp8217s not just about looking outward itamp8217s about stepping outside of yourselfFive Ways to Break the Bubble and Market with Cultural IntelligenceHere are five ways every marketer and brand can avoid falling into the cultural isolation trap1 Practice amp8220Cultural CrossCheckingamp8221Before greenlighting a campaign run it by people outside your immediate ecosystem That doesnamp8217t mean focus groups after the fact It means involving diverse voices at the strategic and conceptual stages Diversity of race geography ideology gender generation and experience Ask What might I not be seeing2 Donamp8217t Confuse Cultural Familiarity with Cultural UniversalityJust because something feels quotnormalquot or amp8220neutralamp8221 to you doesnamp8217t mean itamp8217s apolitical or unproblematic to others Flags landscapes even denim jackets can take on coded meanings Assume nothing is seen the same way by everyone3 Monitor Culture in Layers Not TrendsTrend reports are great but cultural understanding runs deeper than aesthetics What are the conversations happening in the margins On Reddit in rural communities among faithbased Gen Zers Build a layered cultural radar not just a highlights reel4 Encourage Internal DissentThe healthiest creative cultures allow space for respectful pushback If everyone in the room agrees on the idea right away be suspicious Cultivate an environment where someone can say amp8220I think weamp8217re missing something hereamp8221 without fear of being labeled difficult5 Use Controversy as a Mirror Not a ShieldWhen backlash happens donamp8217t default to defensiveness Ask yourself whatamp8217s this really about What did we assume overlook or oversimplify And what does this tell us about the culture we claim to reflectA Final WordThe irony of the Sydney Sweeney x American Eagle moment is that it tried to do something quintessentially American celebrate youth denim and optimism and ended up revealing just how fragmented the idea of amp8220Americanamp8221 has become That doesnamp8217t mean we should retreat from bold ideas or interesting talent But it does mean we must be humble enough to recognize that our own experience of culture is just that our ownGreat marketers donamp8217t just chase relevance They seek resonance And to do that we have to listen amp8211 really listen to the multiplicity of voices that make up our audience Even and especially the ones that arenamp8217t in the roomPosted at MediaVillage through the Thought Leadership selfpublishing platformClick the social buttons to share this story with colleagues and friendsThe opinions expressed here are the author39s views and do not necessarily represent the views of MediaVillageorgMyersBizNet

Become a Thought Leader. Share your thought leadership article with industry professionals & have them archived in Thought Leadership

Culture Clash in the Denim Aisle: What the Sydney Sweeney/American Eagle Controversy Teaches Us About Marketing in a Polarized World

Author

Publish date

Channel

Stephanie Fierman

"About That with Carl Mayer:" Alaina Donnellon (Episode 10: Political Spending) - By Carl Mayer

More Videos:

Become a Thought Leader. Share your thought leadership article with industry professionals & have them archived in Thought Leadership

Culture Clash in the Denim Aisle: What the Sydney Sweeney/American Eagle Controversy Teaches Us About Marketing in a Polarized World

Enjoying This Commentary? There's More to Love

Stephanie Fierman

"About That with Carl Mayer:" Alaina Donnellon (Episode 10: Political Spending) - By Carl Mayer

The payment was successful

Cookies